Disc Protrusion L4 and L5: Do You Really Need Surgery?
Free MRI ReviewLow back and leg pain
By Dr. Mark Frenkel, MD, MA, FAANS, FCNS · Board-certified neurosurgeon and spine surgeon, Naples, Florida ·
The call usually comes after a weekend of yard work or a long drive. A patient describes a deep ache in the low back, then a burning line down the leg, and finally a printed MRI report with disc protrusion at L4-L5 underlined twice. The first question is rarely about pain. It is: “Does this mean I need a fusion?”
For most people, the answer is no. A disc protrusion L4 and L5 sits at one of the two levels that account for most lumbar disc problems, and the majority of patients improve without an operation. Still, some people need a specialist sooner than they think, and a smaller group truly needs surgery.
I'm Dr. Mark Frenkel, a board-certified neurosurgeon and spine surgeon in Naples, Florida. I also invented CemLIF, a lumbar fusion technique that uses bone cement instead of screws and rods. In this guide, I'll explain what the MRI finding means, how it feels, what to try at home, and which warning signs mean you should stop waiting. I'll also be honest about when fusion makes sense and when it doesn't.
The diagnosis, decoded
Your lower back has five lumbar vertebrae, numbered L1 through L5. Between each pair sits a disc: a tough outer ring (the annulus) around a soft, gel-like center (the nucleus). The L4-L5 disc sits between your fourth and fifth lumbar vertebrae, just above the base of the spine. You will also see “disc” spelled “disk”; the two mean the same thing.
MRI reports use four words that sound alike but mean different things:
A protrusion sits between a harmless bulge and a more aggressive extrusion. What matters more than the label is whether the material touches a nerve, and which one.
According to NIH's StatPearls review of lumbar disc herniation, about 95% of lumbar disc herniations occur at L4-L5 or L5-S1. Those two levels carry much of the load and motion of your lower spine. A lateral herniation at L4-L5 typically compresses the L5 nerve root, and L5 radiculopathy is the most common lumbar radiculopathy.
One note on naming. Patients often say “L4 and L5” when they mean the L4-L5 disc. Some reports also list L4-L5 and L5-S1 together. Those are different levels with different nerves, and I'll explain why that matters below.
A protrusion on MRI is a picture, not a verdict. Many adults have one and feel nothing. That is why I match three things before I recommend anything invasive: your symptoms, my neurological exam, and your imaging. If they don't agree, I keep looking.
Causes
Most protrusions don't start with one dramatic event. Discs lose water and flexibility with age, and the outer ring develops small tears. Lumbar herniations tend to peak between ages 30 and 50, and then a trigger finishes the job: a heavy lift with a twist, a long drive, or a sneeze on a disc that has been weakening for years.
An L4-L5 herniated disc also follows a pattern. The lower lumbar discs carry the most load and motion in your spine, so modest strain adds up over the years. That is why people in physically demanding jobs and people who sit all day show up in my clinic with the same MRI finding.
Several factors raise the odds:
You can't change your age or your genes. You can change how you lift, how long you sit without moving, and whether you smoke. I tell patients to put their energy there.
Symptoms
L4-L5 disc protrusion symptoms depend on what the protrusion touches. If it presses on a nerve root, you feel it in the leg. If it presses on nothing, you may feel only a dull back ache, or nothing at all.
Leg pain from a pinched nerve is called sciatica, or radiculopathy. When an L4-L5 protrusion irritates the L5 nerve, doctors call it L5 radiculopathy, and patients typically describe:
| Nerve (usual disc source) | Where you may feel it | Weakness you may notice | Reflex that may fade |
|---|---|---|---|
| L4 (far-lateral L4-L5, or L3-L4) | Inner calf and front of the thigh | Straightening the knee (quadriceps) | Knee jerk |
| L5 (typical L4-L5 protrusion) | Outer calf and top of the foot | Lifting the foot and big toe (foot drop) | No standard reflex to test |
| S1 (typical L5-S1 protrusion) | Outer foot and sole | Pushing off with the calf | Ankle jerk |
Typical patterns drawn from standard neurological references. Individual patients vary.
This is why an “L4 and L5” diagnosis needs care. If your report lists both L4-L5 and L5-S1, my exam tells me which level is actually causing your leg symptoms, and that decides the plan.
Home care vs. specialist
The research is encouraging. A systematic review of 34 articles on disc resorption found that herniated disc material shrank after conservative treatment in 76.6% of patients, although results ranged widely, from 20% to 96.2%. A separate meta-analysis found that most of that shrinkage happens within six months. That is why I start most patients with structured home care, not an operating room.
Two caveats matter. Shrinking on MRI and feeling better are not the same thing, and not everyone improves. Interestingly, larger and extruded fragments tend to resorb more readily than small, contained protrusions, so a dramatic MRI can still carry a good prognosis.
I would rather see you early than late. Beyond the usual L4-L5 disc protrusion symptoms, book an evaluation if any of these apply:
Go to the emergency room today if:
You develop new trouble urinating or controlling your bladder or bowels, numbness in the saddle area (inner thighs, genitals, buttocks, or rectum), new sexual dysfunction, or weakness spreading in both legs. These are the warning signs of cauda equina syndrome, a surgical emergency in which a large disc compresses the bundle of nerves at the base of the spine. It is rare, but delay can cause permanent damage.
Treatment options
Think of disc protrusion treatment as a ladder. You start on the bottom rung and climb only as far as your symptoms require.
When surgery is warranted for an L4-L5 herniated disc, the choice depends on what is wrong beyond the disc itself.
How does surgery compare with waiting? In large randomized comparisons such as the SPORT trial, patients with persistent sciatica improved substantially whether or not they had surgery, and surgery mainly brought faster relief of leg pain. In plain terms, surgery buys speed, and the price is surgical risk. That trade is worth making when you have progressive weakness or disabling pain, and not worth making when you are improving.
Honest surgical advice
Here is something many fusion consultations skip: a disc protrusion alone rarely needs a fusion. If your problem is a single disc pressing on a nerve and your spine is otherwise stable, conservative care or a microdiscectomy is usually the right call, and I'll tell you so. Fusion adds recovery time and risk that a pinched nerve doesn't need.
None of these is automatic. Each has to match your symptoms and your exam before I recommend an operation.
Recurrence deserves a closer look. A review in Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine describes recurrent herniation as the most common reason patients need another operation after a discectomy. But fusion is not automatically the answer. A systematic review of surgery for recurrent herniation found similar satisfactory outcomes with and without instrumented fusion (77.8% versus 79.5%). So I ask whether fusion is needed for this patient, not whether it is possible.
The hardware question
Traditional lumbar fusion stabilizes the level with pedicle screws and rods placed through a posterior incision. It works, and for the right patient it remains a sound operation. But patients deserve to hear the tradeoffs before they hear a surgery date.
Consider adjacent segment disease, where the levels next to a fusion wear out. In a study of 419 patients who had lumbar interbody fusion with percutaneous pedicle screws, 4.77% needed revision surgery for adjacent segment disease, on average 2.5 years after the first operation. The authors noted that no surgical approach may fully prevent it.
That risk comes with any fusion, including mine, because joining one level shifts stress to its neighbors. What hardware adds are separate burdens: dissection through the muscles of the back, a larger incision, and screws and rods that stay in your spine permanently.
A surgeon who welcomes those questions is one you can trust. A second opinion is never an insult, and I encourage them.
Why I built it differently
When fusion is truly warranted, I ask one more question: does this patient need screws and rods at all? That question led me to invent CemLIF, a technique that stabilizes the level with PMMA bone cement instead of pedicle screws and rods. Surgeons have used PMMA in orthopedic surgery since the late 1950s, when Sir John Charnley began cementing hip replacements.
CemLIF has two variants, and they are not interchangeable. CemLIF-L, the lateral approach, treats levels from L1-2 through L4-5, so it is the variant for an L4-L5 disc. CemLIF-A, the anterior approach, treats L5-S1. If your imaging shows trouble at both L4-L5 and L5-S1, I match the variant to each level.
In a CemLIF-L case, I work through a small incision on the side, remove the damaged disc, place a spacer, and inject cement to stabilize the level. The operation takes about 45 minutes per level, and most patients stay one to two days in the hospital. I came to this work as an early adopter of augmented reality in spine surgery, so I care a great deal about precision and about doing less tissue damage.
What CemLIF leaves out
What it uses instead
CemLIF is a fusion operation, so it isn't the answer for a disc protrusion that only needs the nerve decompressed. If your spine is stable and your leg pain comes from a single disc, I will usually point you toward conservative care or a microdiscectomy. CemLIF is also newer than screws-and-rods fusion, which has decades of data behind it, and the cement is an FDA-cleared material used off-label in this setting. Candidacy is individual, and I'll tell you if another approach fits you better.
To learn more, read how CemLIF works, see the conditions CemLIF treats, browse common questions about CemLIF, or hear from patients on our patient success stories page. My broader neurosurgical practice, including decompression surgery, is described at frenkelmd.com.
Your next step
Wondering if CemLIF could be right for your L4-L5 disc?
If you're dealing with a disc protrusion at L4-L5 and want to know whether CemLIF could be right for you, I'd encourage you to schedule a consultation. We'll review your imaging together and give you a straight answer, including what it would cost and what recovery would look like.
Your questions
Often, yes. In a systematic review of 34 articles, herniated disc material shrank after conservative treatment in about 77% of patients, though results varied widely. Most people feel better well before the MRI changes. I judge progress by how your leg feels and works, not by repeat scans, and I watch for weakness or worsening numbness, which means waiting is no longer safe.
Many patients notice meaningful improvement within six to twelve weeks, although numbness can linger longer and shrinkage on MRI can take up to six months. If you aren't improving after about six weeks of good effort, or if your leg is getting weaker, see a spine specialist rather than waiting longer.
Avoid heavy lifting, bending while twisting, and long unbroken stretches of sitting or driving. Don't push through new leg weakness or worsening numbness. Bed rest usually doesn't help; short, frequent walks and gentle movement serve most people better. If a position sends pain down your leg, change it and tell your physical therapist or doctor.
Usually not. A protrusion pressing on a nerve in an otherwise stable spine is typically treated with conservative care or, if needed, a microdiscectomy. I consider fusion for instability, spondylolisthesis, a collapsed disc with chronic back pain, recurrent herniation, or failed prior surgery. The word protrusion on your report doesn't decide it; your exam and imaging do.
Sometimes, when fusion is genuinely warranted. CemLIF-L is the variant for levels from L1-2 through L4-5, so it applies at L4-L5, while CemLIF-A is used at L5-S1. It is not a treatment for every disc protrusion, and many patients are better served by conservative care or discectomy. We decide candidacy together after reviewing your imaging.
The surgical portion of the procedure is generally covered by private insurance and Medicare. The bone cement augmentation is an off-label use of an FDA-cleared material and is typically not covered. The full cost details are in the disclaimer at the end of this article, and our office can walk you through current pricing before you decide anything.
Next step
Not sure whether you need surgery at all?
Bring your MRI and your questions. I'll tell you honestly what I see, including when the right answer is more time, more physical therapy, or a different operation than the one I invented.
The short version
Your next step
A disc protrusion L4 and L5 is common, frightening on paper, and usually manageable. Give home care and physical therapy an honest trial, know the red flags, and don't accept a fusion until someone has explained why your spine needs one.
If your leg is getting weaker, your pain has outlasted six weeks of good effort, or you've been told you need screws and rods and want a second opinion, schedule a consultation at cemlif.com/schedule-a-consultation. We'll review your imaging together and give you a straight answer, including what recovery would look like and what it would cost. If you'd like to ask a question first, contact our office.
Medical disclaimer: The information in this article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Candidacy for CemLIF, including whether CemLIF-A or CemLIF-L is appropriate, is determined on an individualized basis following a thorough consultation with Dr. Frenkel. Results may vary. Always consult a qualified physician before pursuing any surgical or medical treatment.
Cost and insurance disclaimer: The surgical portion of this procedure is generally covered by private insurance and Medicare. The bone cement augmentation is an off-label use of an FDA-cleared material and is typically not covered by insurance, with an estimated out-of-pocket cost of approximately $10,000 per level treated. This cost may be tax-deductible depending on individual circumstances; consult a tax professional for guidance specific to your situation. Pricing is subject to change — contact our office for current information.
Author
Dr. Mark B. Frenkel, MD, MA, FAANS, FCNS is a board-certified neurosurgeon and spine surgeon based in Naples, Florida. He is the inventor of CemLIF, a rod-less, screw-less lumbar fusion technique, a Castle Connolly Top Doctor (2024-2026), and a Healthgrades 99th Percentile physician. Dr. Frenkel has published extensively in peer-reviewed neurosurgical journals. Learn more at cemlif.com/who-we-are.